Is VFV a Good Buy? Understanding Its Limitations
Investing in exchange-traded funds (ETFs) is one of the most efficient ways to gain exposure to various stocks while managing risk. Among Canadian investors, VFV—the Vanguard S&P 500 Index ETF—has gained considerable attention. However, while VFV offers the opportunity to invest in large U.S.-based companies, it is important to understand that it lacks global diversification.
In this blog post, we’ll explore whether VFV is a good buy by examining its strengths, limitations, and potential alternatives, including XEQT, for more globally diversified portfolios.
What is VFV?
VFV is an ETF that tracks the performance of the S&P 500 Index, which consists of the 500 largest publicly traded companies in the United States. Managed by Vanguard, VFV offers Canadian investors exposure to U.S. stocks without having to convert their currency, as it is not currency-hedged.
Key Features of VFV:
- Tracks the S&P 500 Index: Provides access to top U.S. companies like Apple, Microsoft, and Amazon.
- Low Management Fees: VFV boasts a management expense ratio (MER) of 0.08%, one of the lowest among ETFs.
- No Currency Hedging: VFV is exposed to currency fluctuations between the U.S. and Canadian dollars, which can impact returns.
The Appeal of VFV: Why It’s Popular
There are several reasons why VFV is a favorite among Canadian investors:
1. Exposure to Leading U.S. Companies
The S&P 500 represents many of the largest and most successful companies in the world. VFV allows investors to easily buy into global giants like Apple, Microsoft, and Google, all of which dominate their respective industries.
2. Strong Historical Performance
The S&P 500 has historically been a strong performer, averaging 10% annual returns over several decades. This long-term growth is attractive to investors seeking capital appreciation.
3. Low Fees
With an MER of 0.08%, VFV is one of the most cost-effective ETFs available. Over time, low fees can have a significant impact on your investment returns.
The Downside: Lack of Global Diversification
Despite its benefits, VFV has one critical limitation: It only provides exposure to U.S.-based companies, making it heavily dependent on the performance of the U.S. market. Here are some reasons why this could be a disadvantage:
1. Dependence on the U.S. Economy
While U.S. companies have historically performed well, investing exclusively in U.S. equities exposes your portfolio to the risks of a single country. Any downturns in the U.S. economy, such as recessions or political instability, would have a major impact on VFV’s performance.
2. Missed International Growth Opportunities
VFV does not provide exposure to international markets like Asia, Europe, or emerging economies. Some of the fastest-growing companies are located outside the U.S., and by focusing solely on U.S. stocks, you may miss out on these potential high-growth opportunities.
3. Sector Concentration
The S&P 500 is heavily concentrated in technology stocks such as Apple, Microsoft, and Alphabet. While these companies have performed well, sector concentration increases the risk that a downturn in tech could negatively affect the ETF.
Alternatives to VFV: Looking Beyond U.S. Equities
If you’re concerned about VFV’s lack of global diversification, there are several ETF alternatives that provide broader exposure to international markets. Here are some options:
1. XEQT (iShares Core Equity ETF Portfolio)
XEQT is a globally diversified all-equity ETF that offers exposure to stocks from Canada, the U.S., Europe, Asia, and emerging markets. Unlike VFV, XEQT provides a more balanced approach by investing in equities across various global markets, reducing risk associated with focusing on a single country.
- Key Benefit: XEQT offers exposure to both U.S. and international markets, allowing investors to benefit from global growth opportunities.
- MER: 0.20%, slightly higher than VFV but still low for global diversification.
- Risk Level: High, as XEQT is 100% equity, but better diversified than VFV.
2. XAW (iShares MSCI All Country World ex Canada Index ETF)
XAW offers exposure to international markets outside of Canada, including U.S. stocks, international developed markets, and emerging markets. XAW is a good choice for investors who want global diversification but already have sufficient exposure to Canadian equities.
- Key Benefit: Global diversification without Canadian stocks.
- MER: 0.22%.
- Risk Level: High, with broad exposure to global equities.
3. VEQT (Vanguard All-Equity ETF Portfolio)
VEQT is another strong alternative, offering exposure to Canadian, U.S., and international equities. VEQT is a one-ticket solution for investors looking for broad equity diversification and growth potential.
- Key Benefit: Broad global exposure, including Canadian equities.
- MER: 0.24%.
- Risk Level: High, as VEQT is 100% equities.
Should You Buy VFV?
So, is VFV a good buy? It depends on your investment goals and risk tolerance. While VFV provides access to leading U.S. companies and offers low fees, its lack of global diversification could be a drawback for investors seeking more balanced exposure.
When VFV Might Be a Good Buy:
- You want U.S. equity exposure: If your goal is to invest in top U.S. companies with strong growth potential, VFV is an excellent choice.
- You’re focused on long-term growth: VFV’s exposure to large U.S. companies has historically delivered solid long-term returns.
- You want low fees: VFV’s 0.08% MER is ideal for investors who prioritize keeping costs low.
When VFV Might Not Be a Good Buy:
- You want global diversification: If you’re looking for a more balanced portfolio with exposure to other regions, VFV falls short. Consider alternatives like XEQT, XAW, or VEQT for a more globally diversified approach.
- You’re concerned about U.S. market risks: If you’re worried about the possibility of U.S. market downturns, VFV’s heavy reliance on U.S. equities could be too risky.
Conclusion
VFV is a great ETF for investors looking to gain exposure to U.S.-based companies at a low cost. However, it’s important to recognize its limitation—lack of global diversification. For investors who want to hedge against U.S.-specific risks or access growth in international markets, alternatives like XEQT, XAW, or VEQT provide more globally balanced options.
As always, your investment choices should align with your financial goals and risk tolerance. If you’re unsure, consulting with a financial advisor can help you make the best decision for your portfolio.
How do I buy XEQT for free?
The easiest way to buy XEQT for free in Canada is with Wealthsimple. To open an account and get $25 for free, you can use my referral link with promo code: RWT_JQ 🎁.